FUNNYBOOK MUSINGS

Brain Games Is Now... Over

2006-05-24T12:19:00.000-05:00

Remember that show from HBO in the 1980's?

Anyway, I can't continue to publish this blog as my new job eats up almost all of my time. In addition I am not reading comics that regularly anymore so I don't really have much to talk about on the blog. I am going to leave the site up for as long as I can, and who knows? Maybe someday I will start it up again, but this has to be bye for now.

Big thank you to everyone who read each week and everyone that left comments. It was a lot of fun.

-Ryan

REVIEW: Daredevil #84

2006-04-26T07:02:00.000-05:00

Daredevil #84
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Ed Brubaker
Artist: Michael Lark

[*spoiler wanring*] This review may contain spoilers. Read on at your own risk.

Story:
This arc has so far been very good. In this issue, Matt begins "investigating the death of Foggy Nelson using intimidation and violence which I have to say was satisfying to read. In addition, Bullseye joins the inmate population, though as you might have guessed he is kept in solitary under very restrictive circumstances for obvious reasons.

Artwork:
Lark's work has been good, and this issue is no exception. Like Maleev before him, Lark's style suits this title perfectly. The fact that the lion's share of this arc is set at Ryker's only helps to highlight Lark's work. The coloring has been very good also - just dark enough without being to dark.

Overall Impression:
This is currently one of the only titles I look forward to reading with any regularity. This arc has been great so far, and I expect that to continue. This issue was perfectly paced and had enough action to satisfy most DD fans. Highly recommended.

THE VERDICT: 9/10

New Review Format

2006-04-09T19:54:00.000-05:00

You have probably realized that I have started using a new format for my reviews. I think it makes them a bit easier to read, and it definitely makes them easier for me to write. Anyway, let me know what you think.

REVIEW: Y-The Last Man #44

2006-04-09T19:50:00.000-05:00

Y-The Last Man #44
Publisher: DC Vertigo
Writer: Brian K. Vaughan
Artist: Pia Guerra

[*spoiler wanring*] This review may contain spoilers. Read on at your own risk.

Story:
Yorick and Agent 355 are in Tokyo following Ampersand's trail. They encounter a male robot owned by a beautiful woman named You. She is sort of contemporary robot pimp for the sans male post apocalyptic world. One of her customers had used Ampersand as payment. Unfortunately, You had to barter Amp away for protection. "Who'd she sell him too?" You ask? A canadian pop-star.

Artwork:
I like Pia Guerra's work. It is not as detailed as some comic artists, but it is very clean and does a great job telling a story. Panel layout, colors, and pencils are all very good in this issue.

Overall Impression:
This issue begins a new arc for this title. I didn't particularly enjoy the last arc that much, but this issue has renewed my interest in what was once my favorite title. This is a strong issue and hopefully represents a return to glory for this title. This is one you should probably pick up.

THE VERDICT: 8/10

REVIEW: Batman: Secrets #2

2006-04-08T18:18:00.000-05:00

Batman: Secrets #2
Publisher: DC
Writer: Sam Kieth
Artist: Sam Kieth

[*spoiler wanring*] This review may contain spoilers. Read on at your own risk.

Story:
This mini focuses on the Joker's attempts to paint Batman as the bad guy in the eyes of the people of Gotham. While the incident in the first issue was a mere coincidence, in this issue the Joker actively stages scenes for the media that make it look as if Batman is one evil bastard.

Artwork:
I love Kieth's work. I always have, so it should come as no surprise that I am really enjoying the artwork in this mini. Kieth's work is highly stylized, and has a graffiti-like quality to it. If you have never seen it before, give one of these issues a peak the next time you are at the comic shop.

Overall Impression:
I like several things about the concept behind this mini. I like that it really gets into how fickle the confidence of the public can be when confronted with "dubious" photographic evidence as well as the complex roles played by both Batman and Joker in one of the longest running relationships in comicdom. Overall, this issue was a good read with pleasing artwork. The series has a lot to do before it can be called anything more than entertaining, but it is off to a pretty good start.

THE VERDICT: 7.5/10

REVIEW: Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #6

2006-03-21T09:06:00.000-05:00

Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #6
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter David
Artist: Mike Wieringo

It has taken me a few days to get around to writing this review. In the last two weeks, I have only bought 4 comic books. There wasn't a whole lot that came out in that time that I was interested in. I actually read this one last Friday, but I haven't had much time to write anything. So, forgive me, but this review is not going to have much info related to plot - because I can't remember much about it.

Basically, Spidey battles that guy on the cover in a charity wrestling match that was set up by J. Jonah Jameson as a favor to the masked wrassler. The majority of the issue focuses on the fight and is relatively boring because when reading a 40+ year old title about a character that has been around that long, there is little room for anyone to believe that any fight will end with Spidey losing. I will say that if you are not a fan of the bone claws, this issue will likely further annoy you.

Wieringo's artwork is good. I must say that I am really enjoying that aspect of this title a lot. I didn't find this issue very entertaining. It would have been better served by focusing less on the fight and more on the character, but those aren't decisions I get to make. All in all this one was a letdown.

My Verdict: 5/10

REVIEW: Ultimates 2 #10

2006-03-06T16:20:00.000-05:00

Ultimates 2 #10
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Mark Millar
Artist: Bryan Hitch

[*mild spoilers*] I am not going to put any real spoilers because there is really way to much for me to get into here. I will put it to you this way: this is an issue where a lot of sh-t hits a lot of fans. The one thing I do want to mention is that I found it both peculiarly cool and funny that Hawkeye kills several people in this issue with his fingernails. Read it and you will see what I am talking about.

This was a very good issue. I have read better Ultimates issues, but this one is very good. Hitch does some great work this issue with some very tough panels. The mood of this issue is decidedly darker than the past, but definitely worth the extended wait.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #5

2006-03-06T10:28:00.000-05:00

Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #5
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter David
Artist: Mike Wieringo

[*mild spoilers*] This was a really strange stand-alone story about a woman who feels that Spider-Man is "stalking" her. It is told, for the most part, by way of the woman's blog. She somehow gets a judge to approve a restraining order against the web-slinger, and then decades later is confronted by Mary Jane.

This wasn't really what I was expecting for the first non-"The Other" story for this title. While it was well written and somewhat entertaining, I can't help but scratch my head. There really is nothing more to say about it. It was weird.

My Verdict: 6/10

REVIEW: Batman Annual #25

2006-03-03T08:50:00.000-05:00

Batman Annual #25
Publisher: DC
Writer: Judd Winick
Artist: Shane Davis

[*spoiler warning*] If you were wondering (like me) how the hell Jason Todd ended up alive again, this is a definite must read. The entire purpose of this issue is to explain it to us. Are you ready for the reason? Get ready, here it comes. Jason Todd was brought back from the dead by magic. They don't call it magic, but make no mistake, that's what it is.

This was an important issue story wise, but very silly if you ask me. I don't find the explanation for why Jason is back from the dead to be interesting or even well planned. There is nothing wrong with the execution of the story, and the artwork is actually quite good. But, as far as intrigue goes; there is none here.

My Verdict: 6/10

REVIEW: American Way #1

2006-02-28T11:01:00.000-05:00

American Way #1
Publisher: WildStorm
Writer: John Ridley
Artist: Georges Jeanty

[*spoiler warning*] Before you read my review, I need to make something clear: I may ruin this issue for you if you have not read it already. That said, if you are not sure whether to get this or not, let me just say that I think you should. In fact, it is one of the better books in recent memory. So, if you are okay with massive spoilers read on.

WOW! This issue was fabulous. I picked this up to try something new and it really paid off.

The year is 1961, and America is as you might expect with a few very common comic book exceptions. First, there are superheroes; and second, there are aliens. The story follows a PR man for a car company that is fired after the failure of the model he promotes. He is called to Washington DC by an old friend from school: Bobby Kennedy. Kennedy offers him a job and gives him access to some very scandalous information. What follows is that information and it is a huge spoiler.

Kennedy explains that the supposed "superheroes" are nothing more than people with decent and sometimes amazing abilities that are acting out heroism on the grandest stage: real life. Every encounter reported in the paper, every super-villain, the aliens, they are all fake. Special effects and actors all staged for the public's benefit. Essentially they are all part of the government PR machine, and nobody knows it.

At the end of the issue, the most popular heroes dies from a fall. The book ends and we are left wondering how the government will handle this PR disaster. If that doesn't sound like the makings of a great title, I don't know what does.

The artwork is great this issue. Great detail with very nice coloring that actually makes the book feel more "60's." It is not a quick read, which is a good thing and also very rare these days. I cannot recommend this book more highly. Everyone should be reading this.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: Amazing Spider-Man #529

2006-02-27T13:14:00.000-05:00

Amazing Spider-Man #529
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: J. Michael Straczynski
Artist: Ron Garney

[*spoiler warning*] This issue sold out fast! Many of you probably missed the first printing, but do not despair. The good people at Marvel are printing more!

As the cover clearly indicates, this is the first issue featuring the web-slinger in his new duds. I am really torn over this issue. I can't say I am that big a fan of the new look for the character, and after reading this issue it sounds as if Spidey's new suit makes him almost invincible. But, I know that the change is temporary and that is a small comfort. I guess I just liked the stories about a loner hero that made his own costume. On a positive note, this issue read like an old school Spidey issue. There was a short action sequence in which Spidey took on some hoods. Then we got some foundation for the rest of the upcoming "Civil War" event. I liked the artwork on the book, and I thought the story was pretty entertaining. I do however question how anyones leg can bend the way Spidey's does on the cover. This one is recommended.

My Verdict: 8/10

REVIEW: Ultimate Wolverine vs. Hulk #2

2006-02-26T20:27:00.000-05:00

Ultimate Wolverine vs. Hulk #2
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Damon Lindelof
Artist: Leinil Francis Yu

[*spoiler warning*] You that kick-ass, really cool cover to the left? That really gets you in the mood to read a super cool issue with some super cool fighting between Hulk and Wolvie, right? I mean, the first issue opened with Wolverine cut in half. This issue is going to Rock!

Well, I hate to break it to you, but the cover of this book has nothing to do with what is inside the issue. A more accurate cover would feature Bruce Banner thinking or talking. Yep, this issue is all about Ultimate Bruce Banner coming to grips with his alter-self Ultimate Hulk. If that wasn't enough, he also seeks the advice of a Buddhist monk second in line to the Dahlai Llama. Boooooooorinnnnng. This issue sucked. I was really hoping that this mini would be a series of very cool stories covering a different aspects of a fight between these two brutes. No such luck. Hopefully future issues will feature less talking and more fighting.

My Verdict: 3/10

REVIEW: Astonishing X-Men #13

2006-02-26T20:18:00.000-05:00

Astonishing X-Men #13
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Joss Whedon
Artist: John Cassaday

[*mild spoilers*] Finally. This issue finally shipped! I can't much remember what was happening in the series, but I read this anyway. As expected, Cassaday's artwork was great. The story, unfortunately, didn't grab me so well. This arc is headed for some major Hellfire club action, and while they are cool villains, I just read an arc in Uncanny a few months ago that featured them. I am not really excited about the prospect of reading another one. There were two very entertaining scenes in this issue. The first featured Wolverine "teaching" the students their combat lesson without the aid of the now empty Danger Room. There is a great little moment in that scene. The other scene takes place at the end of the issue as Emma is trying to get Scott to come to bed. You have to read it to find out what I am talking about, but it got a chuckle out of me.

All in all this wasn't a bad issue, it just didn't feel as big as I remember this series being. I'm going with a moderate recommendation on this one.

My Verdict: 7/10

REVIEW: The Roach #1

2006-02-23T16:34:00.000-05:00

The Roach #1
Publisher: Black Ink! Imprints
Writer: Robert Roach
Artist: Robert Roach

Oh no, another indy book I didn't like. This one was almost unreadable for me. In fact, I couldn't finish it. It is essentially the story of an assasin named "the Roach." Who takes on a large bureaucratic organization called "the Cause," but other than that, it makes little sense. Some of the artwork is cool looking at first, but does little to help the story along. In certain areas it makes it quite difficult to figure out what is going on. In addition, Robert Roach seems obsessed with wrinkles in clothing as there are thousands rendered in this book. Perhaps it was all supposed to be a satire of the genre. If so, I didn't get it. I will give it a little credit for the artwork because it has a lot of detail, but other than that there is little to sink your teeth into.

My Verdict: 2.5/10

REVIEW: Captain America #15

2006-02-23T11:50:00.000-05:00

Captain America #15
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Ed Brubaker
Artist: Mike Perkins

[*mild spoilers*] This issue centers on Red Skulls daughter who has been kidnapped by Crossbones. She doesn't remember her rotten past, but Crossbones is determined to refresh her memory.

This is a very dark issue. There are some "scenes" which made me shift in my seat some because they were pretty brutal. Brubaker does a brilliant job showing the sadistic side of the villains in this issue, and Perkins artwork is riveting. Following the amazing first arc of this new title, this one promises to be even better. This was a strong first issue, and comes very highly recommended.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: Batman #650

2006-02-22T18:23:00.000-05:00

Batman #650
Publisher: DC Comics
Writer: Judd Winick
Artist: Eric Battle

[*spoiler warning*] Many people are not pleased with the direction Batman has taken recently, and I imagine that will not change for many after reading this issue. But, I for one am really enjoying the Bat-dick and really liked this issue. For the record, this is the last issue before we jump to One Year Later.

In this issue, Jason and Bats get into a brawl and Jason questions Batman why he has never killed the Joker. Todd's reasoning for this question is that the Joker is the guy that killed him and countless others. In response, Batman states that he has thought about torturing and killing the Joker countless times but "he can't do it" because then " he could never go back." I, like Jason, find that to be a load of superhero BS and Jason gives Bats a simple choice: Kill Jason, or Jason kills the Joker. Want to know more? Read the issue. I guarantee you will feel strongly about this issue one way or the other.

This was a great issue of this sagging series with tons of drama. There was also a lot of important questions asked about Batman and superheros in general. The art was also very strong this issue, so I would definitely say you need to at least check it out at your LCS.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: The Portent #1

2006-02-22T18:17:00.000-05:00

The Portent #1
Publisher: Image
Writer: Peter Bergting
Artist: Peter Bergting

[*mild spoilers*] Trying this issue was pure speculation on my part. I am trying to expand my comic horizon and this represents one of those attempts. But, sadly this title just didn't work for me. It is a fantasy title and reads somewhat like a classic "quest" story except I had trouble at points understanding what was happening. In addition, toward the end of the issue the dialogue becomes so contemporary that it jarred me right out of any fantastical sense I may have had. But, by far my biggest gripe with this issue is the fact that it is yet another "chosen one" stories. This is such a played out plotline, especially in fantasy, that I can no longer read these stories with an open mind.

I did not care for this issue. The art is okay, but unremarkable, and the issue failed to grab my attention. Rabid fantasy fans may get something out of this issue, but I did not.

My Verdict: 4/10

Reviews This Week

2006-02-22T15:08:00.000-05:00

As you may have noticed, I am getting very ambitious this week with my review schedule. I will try and get them all done as quickly as possible so bear with me. There are a bunch of new indy titles on there as well, so I may end up finding us something we can all enjoy!

REVIEW: Butternut Squash #1

2006-02-17T09:35:00.000-05:00

Butternut Squash #1
Publisher: Speakeasy Comics
Writer: Ramon Perez
Artist: Rob Coughler

I decided to give this title a try this week for no other reason than I wanted to start buying more indy stuff. I think I may have picked the wrong book because I didn't really care for this one. The book is basically a collection of strips featuring three friends that all seem pretty identical to me. There are about a dozen strips that are about coffee and aren't funny anymore after the third time you've read the same joke. I chuckled a few times, but not anymore than I do when I read Family Circus - and I don't like Family Circus.

The artwork is in the style of a modern cartoon, and while it isn't bad, it would fit better with a full 22 page story. But, I am not going to complain much about the artwork since I generally found it to be good. There is also a whole bunch of extras at the end, but since I didn't like the issue I didn't read any of the extras. I won't be buying another issue of this title.

My Verdict: 3/10

REVIEW: New Avengers #16

2006-02-17T09:04:00.000-05:00

New Avengers #16
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Brian Michael Bendis
Artist: Steve McNiven

[*spoiler warning*] I want to start by saying that this issue went by verrry quickly. Part of the reason for that is that the first several pages are just splash pages with no words on them. See that cover? Well, those guys aren't in this issue! How's that for false advertising? Instead, we get some guy riding a tail of flame and a bunch of SHIELD grunts. Oh, and I can't forget Alpha Flight who have apparently been killed; off panel within a span of 4 pages. But don't worry, it looks like the New Avengers are going to be in the next issue of their own series. If your sarcasm meter went off on that last sentence, I have done my job.

I was disappointed with this issue. The only real major event in it is the apparent death of Alpha Flight which has nerds everywhere up in arms. It really doesn't bother me at all. I sort of liked Puck and Sasquatch, but I can live without them around. Besides, we all know they won't stay dead long.

What really annoyed me about this issue is that we never actually see how the new villain does his killing. That all appears off panel. That was obnoxious. Also, this issue is so decompressed it is ridiculous - I am growing tired of that style. McNiven's art is nice at points, but one panel that features a bunch of SHIELD agents in the background made me die laughing. All of them look like toy soldiers. See if you can find the panel I'm talking about.

By the way, you also get a backup story featuring Kickers Inc. from the New Universe. I didn't read it because it looked really stupid.

I can't really recommend this one unless you are a die hard fan or a completist.

My Verdict: 4/10

REVIEW: Angry Youth Comix #10

2006-02-16T23:19:00.000-05:00

Angry Youth Comix #10
Publisher: Fantagraphics Books
Writer: Johnny Ryan
Artist: Johnny Ryan

I just started reading AYC a little while ago, and while it isn't really for everyone, I enjoy it. For those of you that are unfamiliar with it, it is an extremely raunchy yet extremely funny comic. This issue is a collection of one panel "editorial-type" cartoons with one thing in common: they are all pretty risque. I liked a lot of them, but there were a few racial ones that made me cringe. You aren't going to see any Johnny Ryan cartoons in The New Yorker anytime soon. But that isn't to say his work is devoid of talent. It just isn't high brow in the classic sense.

A normal issue of this title has an almost Seinfeldian feel to it. In that several stories weave themselves into a cohesive plot. Ryan's cartooning style is simplistic but very effective. While I do recommend this title to anyone with a strong stomach and depraved sense of humor, those of you that find Southpark offensive do not want to even look inside AYC.

This issue is strong, but not representitive of the series and a bad point for most people to start reading.

My Verdict: 7.5/10

REVIEW: Jonah Hex #4

2006-02-14T11:13:00.000-05:00

Jonah Hex #4
Publisher: DC
Writer: Justin Gray and Jimmy Palmiotti
Artist: Luke Ross

[*mild spoilers*] This is yet another fabulous issue of one hell of a good new series from DC. This book is so much fun to read. The artwork is beautiful, the dialogue is well written, and the stories are intriguing self contained tales that will leave you wanting more. If that sounds like copy from an advertisement for this title; I don't care. I will gladly pimp this series to anyone that will listen.

In this issue, Jonah brings in a bounty to a strange town. After a cold conversation with the mayor of the town, Jonah decides to hang around while he waits to be paid. A conspiracy of sorts unfolds with a climactic ending that left me a little speechless.

Definitely check this one out. If not for the great stories, then for Luke Ross's outstanding art. You are all going to love this title - trust me.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: JLA #125

2006-02-10T14:50:00.000-05:00

JLA #125
Publisher: DC
Writer: Bob Harras
Artist: Tom Derenick

[*spoiler warning*] This is the last issue of JLA in this incarnation. They are supposedly launching a new title in the near future, but I haven't really paid much attention to new announcements.

As the cover indicates, this issue features the "dramatic" climax to the fight between Ollie and Bats. Key plays a prominent role in the fight, as does Envy. In the end, the physical battle ends, but the war of words see no such resolution. The ex-JLAers decide to put aside their differences momentarily to complete the task at hand: defeating Key.

Once they have subdued the villain, Batman wants to return him to Arkham Asylum. The others are not of the same mind. Ollie, and Dawn don't believe sending him back to Arkham will end the problem. Without warning Dawn uses her powers to send him to... (you have to take a look at the issue to find out where).

I have to say that I am not really sure why DC feels it necessary to reboot this title, but this issue seemed like anything but a finale. There are so many loose ends at the end of this book, there will be plenty to tackle in 52. Overall, the issue was entertaining, but far from the quality I had hoped for.

My Verdict: 6.5/10

REVIEW: Fables #46

2006-02-09T10:15:00.000-05:00

Fable #46
Publisher: DC Vertigo
Writer: Bill Willingham
Artist: Jim Fern

This is the first part of a 2-part story. If that sounds like filler to you, it doesn't get any better when you start reading. In fact, if you actually finish reading this issue, you should be very proud of yourself. Most that try shoot out the back of their throat by page 7. I simply put the issue down, which saved my life.

There is a guest artist on this issue and I really did not care for the artwork. I know nothing about Fern, but his art did nothing for me. I found it very difficult to follow, and far to simplistic and jagged for my taste. The artwork reminds me of ancient japanese art as it is very angular and very simplistic. Another draw back to this issue is the choice of font for much of the lettering. All of the narration is rendered in a cursive font that is so hard on the eyes, it had me straining the entire time.

I do not reccomend this issue to anyone.

My Verdict: 1/10

REVIEW: Uncanny X-Men #469

2006-02-03T08:45:00.000-05:00

Uncanny X-Men #469
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Chris Claremont
Artist: Billy Tan

This issue is the first in a new 3-issue arc, which again focuses on Rachel Grey. While some may be enjoying the recent direction of this title, I have to say that I am not. It feels more like a lesson in continuity to me than a story.

I did, however, really enjoy Billy Tan's artwork. I like his highly stylized pencils a lot and I think they work well for a book like this one. Sorry I don't have more to say. This one just isn't doing much for me.

My Verdict: 5/10

REVIEW: X-Factor #3

2006-02-02T14:58:00.000-05:00

X-Factor #3
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter David
Artist: Ryan Sook

I loved this issue. Layla Miller plays a big part in this one, but there is plenty of action involving the other characters. What was so great about this issue was that it felt like a complete issue to me. It had a beginning, middle, and end. While there are still lose ends at the end, there is also a resolution to the main plot of the issue. I am not going to reveal any of the plot because I do not want to ruin all of the twists in this issue.

This book features great mystery writing as well as great mutant writing, and I am enjoying the series a lot. I also love the pencil work and the colors on this title. They fit the tone of the book perfectly. Definitely check this out.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: Captain America #14

2006-02-02T11:09:00.000-05:00

Captain America #14
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Ed Brubaker
Artist: Steve Epting

[*spoiler warning*] This was the conclusion to the Winter Soldier storyline. By this issue, most readers should have been amply convinced that the mystery man in this story arc was Bucky. If they weren't, they are after reading this issue. It is clear in this issue that Bucky is indeed alive. But, that doesn't necessarily mean what you may all be thinking. Read this issue to find out what I am talking about.

Marvel will definitely be doing something else with Bucky down the line. Whether that is in Capt. America or in another book, I feel like we haven't seen the last of him. Proponents of the "nobody stays dead in comics" can put another notch in their bedpost. This was among one of the more unlikely characters in the MU to return from the dead.

This was a great issue, and a perfect conclusion to a story that has captivated me for months. Epting does a nice job with the art, and Brubaker's story is great. This is definitely worth a look.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: Y-The Last Man #42

2006-02-02T08:42:00.000-05:00

Y-The Last Man #42
Publisher: Vertigo
Writer: Brian K. Vaughan
Artist: Goran Sudzuka

[*spoiler warning*] As the cover suggests, this issue deals mainly with Ampersand. More specifically, it tells the "origin" story of the little monkey. We find out that Ampersand was a lab monkey that was injected with something that should have been lethal. He was shipped to Dr. Mann, but during shipping he was mixed up with another monkey that was going to Yorick as a helper monkey. This is a pretty big development in the story, and gives another important hint to work with while we try to figure this intriguing story out.

All of that being said, this issue still seems a little "light" to me. Storywise, it doesn't have the normal amount of drama that I have come to expect. While Amps story is interesting, at times it feels stretched out in order to fit 22 pages.

My Verdict: 7/10

REVIEW: Gotham Central #40

2006-02-01T19:42:00.000-05:00

Gotham Central #40
Publisher: DC
Writer: Greg Rucka
Artist: Kano

[*spoiler warning*] Sadly, this is the final issue of this unbelievably good series. I am pretty disappointed at that as it was one of my favorites. Apparently, DC is coming out with a new series called Streets of Gotham or something like that, but I doubt it will be the same as this. Anyway, as the cover picture indicates, Montoya turns in her badge at the end of this issue.

The cops are unsuccessful at pinning Corrigan for the recent murder of another officer, and Montoya cannot handle. There is a ton of drama on every page on this issue, but there are also a lot of lose ends at the end of the issue. This gives me hope that the story will go on in the new title.

The artwork is sensational once again. Kano is brilliant when it comes to expression, tension and drama. It hardly seems necessary for their to be words in the book at all. Kano's art tells enough of the story on its own. This is not to say that Rucka is any kind of slouch. He's not. His words are equally impressive. This title will be deeply missed by this fan, and I hope you will all take a look at this great issue.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: Amazing Spider-Man #528

2006-01-29T22:43:00.000-05:00

Amazing Spider-Man #528
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: J. Michael Straczynski
Artist: Mike Deodato Jr.

[*spoiler warning*] This issue marks the end of the 12 issue "The Other" storyline. While some of you may have thought it was a disaster, I feel like it may become something interesting after all. Initially I was not really into it, but after thinking about it and reading an article by Peter David in Comics Buyer's Guide this month; I am willing to give the "new" Spidey a chance. I highly recommend David's article to you all. It contains some great insight on the character.

In this issue, Spidey rescues a small girl from a collapsed building in classic Spidey style. We learn about a few new "powers" that Spidey has acquired since his transformation. One of these powers is, again, annoying. But after reading Peter David's article, I am not that upset about it. In the last panel we get a glimpse of the new outfit that has been all over the internet.

The artwork was decent. My one complaint is that Spidey's physique goes from somewhat normal at points to totally ripped at others. I liked this final issue. Overall, I give the event a mediocre grade, but this issue is worth a read.

My Verdict: 8/10

REVIEW: The Thing #3

2006-01-29T22:35:00.000-05:00

The Thing #3
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Dan Slott
Artist: Andrea Di Vito

Another strong 22 pages of comic goodness from Dan Slott with this issue. How with the Thing get off of Arcade's island? You'll have to read to find out. I don't mean to sound like someone from Marvel's PR department, but I really don't want to spoil this for you, and I feel like a lot of you may be buying Slott's stuff in trade.

My one complaint with this issue was that the artwork left a little to be desired. Even the coloring got on my nerves a bit. Other than that, this was high entertainment.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: New Avengers #15

2006-01-27T22:20:00.000-05:00

New Avengers #15
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Brian Michael Bendis
Artist: Frank Cho

[*spoiler warning*] It's happened, blogs have made it into comics. In this issue, we have the pleasure of reading Warbird's blog. And while Bendis has made his views known on the subject of blogs, there was a minimum of ridicule in its tone.

In this issue, the new Avengers lineup is revealed to the world. That goes over somewhat well, but a familiar Spidey foe makes an appearance which causes some considerable anxiety. At the end of the book we learn that Spider-Woman may in fact not have been telling the truth last issue in her conversation with Cap.

The story and artwork are both good here. Cho's work grew on me throughout the issue. I recommend this to everyone.

My Verdict: 8.5/10

REVIEW: Batman #649

2006-01-27T13:21:00.000-05:00

Batman #649
Publisher: DC
Writer: Judd Winick
Artist: Doug Mahnke

[*spoiler warning*] I have enjoyed much of the recent Batman story taking place in the main title. When we left off in issue 648, Black Mask had stabbed Red Hood through the chest. In this issue, it is revealed that Jason Todd was not the person in the costume. He has kidnapped the Joker, and is holding him in another location.

There is a very revealing, very interesting conversation in this issue between Jason and the Joker. Much of it has been revealed on various message boards, but Batfans should definitely read this issue.

So, I liked this issue. It offers a good amount of substance, and sets up another big standoff between Todd and Bats next issue.

My Verdict: 8/10

REVIEW: Daredevil #81

2006-01-26T23:52:00.000-05:00

Daredevil #81
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Brian Michael Bendis
Artist: Alex Maleev

[*spoiler warning*] This is Brian Michael Bendis' last issue of Dardevil after many strong years. For me, he has made the character interesting again and added many dimensions to an already extensive characterization. Some of his issues were among the best of any given week for me, and I thoroughly enjoyed reading the title. But, don't despair. Ed Brubaker will be taking over next month, and I am excited to see where he takes the title.

In this issue, the "pre-trial" for Matt begins. When Murdock is asked to enter his plea, a bizarre "day dream" occurs in which we see what could be were Matt to fight his way out the courtroom. But he realizes the futility of life on the run, and resigns himself to a plea of not guilty.

His bail is denied and he is sent to a special cell at Rikers Island. So, Brubaker is going to have plenty to work with from the start. Maleev's work is superb as always. Each page is a work of art. Sadly, he is also leaving the book with Bendis, but I look forward to picking up future projects featuring his work.

This was a strong conclusion to an outstanding run of this title. Highly recommended. Pick this one up for sure if you are going to be buying Brubaker's run.

My Verdict: 9/10

Review Archives Removed From Blog

2006-01-23T15:38:00.000-05:00

I have removed the review archives from the side bar in order to make some space. I will keep three weeks of review links up on the side bar at all times. If you want to read an older review, you will need to look in the site archives by month (on the sidebar). My sidebar was getting huge, and old reviews are not all that popular.

I will also be re-doing the recommended reading area on the sidebar. Instead of linking to their Amazon pages, I am going to right an extensive review for each one so look for that soon. New reviews coming on Wednesday. Big week this week.

REVIEW: Spider-Man (Marvel Knights) #22

2006-01-19T22:28:00.000-05:00

Spider-Man (Marvel Knights) #22
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Reginald Hudlin
Artist: Pat Lee

[*spoiler warning*] As I said before in my review of FN Spider-Man, this is more of a continuation of that review as they read almost like a single issue. And also because I don't feel like going back and looking at the issues again, and I can't completely remember what happened in which issue.

After the events of part 10 of the story (FNSM #4), we learn a bit more about the new spidey. For one, he has wolverine like knives that come out of his wrists. Just great, Wolverine is even in a book he's not really in - how original Marvel. In addition the villain is made entirely from spiders (flesh eating spiders). So, yeah, this issue was pretty strange. But not all that fun. Also, Pat Lee's art is... well it's Pat Lee's art; and I don't like it. His humans don't look human.

Anyway, this one was worse than FNSM, so it gets a lower score. Here's to this whole "The Other" storyline being over next week. Cheers!

My Verdict: 4/10

REVIEW: Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #4

2006-01-19T14:41:00.000-05:00

Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #4
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter David
Artist: Mike Wieringo

[*spoiler warning*] Awwwwwwwww. Doesn't that cover just warm your heart? No, seriously... it's an okay cover. Certainly better than a pic of spidey just standing around looking tough or swinging from a lamp post - yawn.

I apologize, but I am writing this review from work and since there were two issues from "The Other" arc out this week I may include some info from the other issue in this review and vice versa. So, think of this review and my review for MK #22 as one big review. I have a slightly bad short term memory.

I'll setup the plot here: Spidey is okay, but he has a really heightened spidey sense. Oh, and Mary Jane has decided that she really loves him. I bet you didn't see that coming. More plot points to follow in the MK #22 review.

So, what did I think about this issue? I was underwhelmed. It felt like filler to me. Marvel could have easily squeezed both this story and the story from MK #22 into one issue. There is far too much space used up saying far too little in this issue. I like Wieringo's artwork, so no problem there. But I do know that many out there are not as fond of his style. So, buy this one at your own risk.

My Verdict: 5.5/10

REVIEW: Infinite Crisis #4

2006-01-19T09:02:00.000-05:00

Infinite Crisis #4
Publisher: DC
Writer: Geoff Johns
Artist: Phil Jiminez

First, a confession: I only read the first three pages of this book. So I am not even going to venture a guess as to how good it was. But I do want to talk about why I only read 3 pages, and let you all know why I think that is.

After reading the first issue of this mega event, I was excited. I thought the first issue was interesting and very informative. I liked the art, and I felt like Johns did a good job bringing me up to speed on all of the events that led to this 7 issue mini. But, after reading (or trying to read) the last 3 issues, I am really finding myself lost all over again. I don't know enough about the DC multiverse or this new crisis to feel comfortable reading all of this. I feel like this story suffers because it can't stand alone, and because fans that are not regular DC readers will be absolutely lost. It seems to me that a company should use these types of events to get more people on board with their particular universe, but this seems to do the opposite.

We've all seen the sales figures. Each one of the IC issues is absolutely destroying everything else, but how many of those people are buying other DC books that weren't already? I suspect only a few, not nearly the number of readers that are ONLY buying Infinite Crisis. I read about 6 other DC titles on a regular basis and I like them. And I will eventually read Infinite Crisis once I do some more research on the DCU, but this mini is doing nothing to make me want to read MORE DC. What about you?

REVIEW: Uncanny X-Men #468

2006-01-19T08:51:00.000-05:00

Uncanny X-Men #468
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Chris Claremont
Artist: Chris Bachalo

[*mild spoilers*] Well, apparently I haven't been paying a whole lot of attention to this title lately because this was a conclusion to a 3-part storyline, and I had no idea what was truly going on. But, I suspect that was my fault, and I read on anyway. The issue is very dark, and centers on Rachel Grey (Jean Grey's daughter?) and her struggles with current foes and past demons. Was that a vague enough plot summary? Good. It should be. That was really all I retained from the issue.

Here's what I can say about the issue. The artwork was very good. Dark and bleak with some good detail. I liked most of the layouts, and I liked the coloring. It seems like the next arc will center on Rachel Grey as well, and she sounds pissed - though about what, I truly have either forgotten or never understood in the first place. Here's to hoping this title can regain my interest as it was my favorite growing up.

My Verdict: 6.5/10

The New Look

2006-01-18T09:56:00.000-05:00

I put some new clothes on the blog this morning. There's still a little bit of tweaking to be done, but I think it looks okay for now.

New reviews starting tonight.

REVIEW: She-Hulk 2 #4

2006-01-14T21:14:00.000-05:00

She-Hulk 2 #4
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Dan Slott
Artist: Scott Kolins

[*mild spoilers*] Everyone knows how much I like the series, and you all should be reading this book. In this issue, Slott looks back at the events in the old Avengers title where She-Hulk goes berserk, and the Avengers are forced to battle it out with her. The story takes us to the town She-Hulk destroyed as Jen helps with the recovery. A murder mystery breaks out and makes for very interesting reading.

Great story, great dialogue. The art is good, but as always with Kolins, you either like him or not. He has a verrrrry unique style. I didn't like him initially, but he has grown on me. This one is highly recommended.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: JLA #124

2006-01-13T08:42:00.000-05:00

JLA #124
Publisher: DC
Writer: Bob Harras
Artist: Tom Derenick

[*mild spoilers*] I honestly don't know much about the super-villain Envy. In fact, all I have as reference is what I have read in the last few issues of JLA, but that hasn't stopped me from enjoying the current arc of JLA. In this issue, Envy shows up in Gotham as Batman and Green Arrow battle him to save Dawn. The real major development comes toward the end of the issue when Green Arrow falls under the influence of Envy and attacks Batman. The physical contest is actually not all that interesting (at least to me). The verbal confrontation, however, makes for extremely interesting reading. Ollie goes off on Batman and most of what he is saying will ring true with most fanboys and girls. Whether it ends up being Ollie's true feelings or induced by Envy's manipulation of his mind, we'll have to wait and see. But it was entertaining just the same. Batman has been a dick for a while now, and Ollie really gives him an earfull about it.

I have come to except a certain style of artwork on this title. Bright colors and perstpective filled panels have become standard in my mind. So, this issue did not disappoint. Derenick's work on this issue is quite good. It has a very slight "cartoon" feel to it which I think suits the story perfectly. Pick this one up, it's a pretty good issue.

My Verdict: 8/10

REVIEW: Fables #45

2006-01-13T08:41:00.000-05:00

Fables #45
Publisher: DC Vertigo
Writer: Bill Willingham
Artist: Mark Buckingham

[*spoiler warning*] This issue is the conclusion to the "Arabian Nights" storyline which started off rather slow, but picked up quickly and ended not so much with a bang, but enough story developments to make it all seem worthwhile.

Sinbad's fate is decided. He is sent back to Baghdad, which we find out is actually still in the homelands, and we learn what Boy Blue's days will be like in "hard labor" up at the farm. It seems that he won't be doing to much work there after all.

For a story that started off with so little interest from me, it steadily picked up, and I rather enjoyed this issue. Sorry for the short review, but I don't have anything to deep to say about this one: it was pretty good. How's that?

My Verdict: 7.5/10

A Note About Comments

2006-01-12T09:36:00.000-05:00

I've had to make a change to the way comments are processed here on FBM. As many people have probably realized from other blogs all over the net, the comment spam problem has now become major. It isn't approaching email spam problems yet, but it is getting there.

So, in an effort to quell the number of penis-enlargementesque comments I receive, I will be reviewing every comment before it makes it's way on to the site. This will delay your comment appearing, but I will be trying hard to review these at least once a day. Rest assured, I will not delete any comments from actual people no matter how bad they may be. Wanna call me a dickface? Go right ahead; I'll post it on the site. Just don't spam me!

Now, if only somebody would leave a comment...

REVIEW: Jonah Hex #3

2006-01-09T17:30:00.000-05:00

Jonah Hex #3
Publisher: DC
Writer: Justin Gray and Jimmy Palmiotti
Artist: Luke Ross

[*spoiler warning*] You want to know why I like this book so much? Well, I'll tell you anyway. Each issue is a stand alone story. I don't need to remember several months of story in order to enjoy a new issue of Jonah Hex. I have enough going on in my life already, not to mention the amount I read each month, that I shouldn't have to have a near perfect memory all the time. So, that's why I like it so much... and, it has damn good stories and art!

This issue is another stand alone and concerns a corrupt Sheriff and the horrible crimes he has been committing on wagon caravans. Eventually laying blame on the Apache's in the area. But, Jonah comes to town and gets that all sorted out. Jonah Hex is a western Punisher, and I love the Punisher so it should come as no surprise that I love Hex too. Luke Hoss's artwork is just wonderful, with dynamic layouts and perfect transition from panel to panel and page to page. Definitely give this issue a look.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: Y-The Last Man #41

2006-01-09T17:22:00.000-05:00

Y-The Last Man #41
Publisher: Vertigo
Writer: Brian K. Vaughan
Artist: Goran Sudzuka

[*mild spoilers*] I never thought I would be saying this, but I think YTLM is starting to slip. Just slightly, but slipping none the less. The story just seems to be languishing a bit. This issue was not bad, it just wasn't as good as previous issues. The major storyline in this issue concerns Agent 355's background/origin, and features a somewhat meandering plot recounting several earlier experiences of the character. It wasn't that any of the issue was that boring, it just didn't seem to move the story much at all. Oh well, I'm going to keep reading - that's for sure!

My Verdict: 7/10

REVIEW: Gotham Central #39

2006-01-09T17:18:00.000-05:00

Gotham Central #39
Publisher: DC
Writer: Greg Rucka
Artist: Kano

[*spoiler warning*] Two words: great issue! The first four pages contain no dialogue or narration and represent one of the best examples of storytelling through pictures I have ever seen. Seriously, even if you don't have any interest in reading this issue, check out the first four pages and tell me they aren't amazing - I dare you.

The rest of the book ain't too shabby either. The story reads like an episode of CSI with a big heap of Internal Affairs mixed in. There is some great dialogue in this issue and a lot of story to devour. It is the second part of an arc, so you may want to pick up the previous issue as well if you don't already own it.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: The Punisher #29

2006-01-09T15:40:00.000-05:00

The Punisher #29
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Garth Ennis
Artist: Leandro Fernandez

[*mild spoilers*] If you're not reading The Punisher, you are missing out on some great stories. This was another extremely strong issue from Ennis and Fernandez. This, the penultimate issue of the current arc: The Slavers, offers plenty of gore. In fact, it is one of the few comics I can remember in recent times that actually made feel a little sick. The last scene is so disturbing it felt almost real to me. Yet, even with all the violence I found myself agreeing almost completely with the Punisher's position. This whole arc as well as every arc in this series is worth a look. The artwork and stories have been really impressive, and this issue only continues that tradition. I highly recommend this to all of you.

My Verdict: 9.5/10

REVIEW: Colossus Bloodline #5

2006-01-08T21:49:00.000-05:00

Colossus Bloodline #5
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: David Hine
Artist: Jorge Lucas

[*spoiler warning*] This is the final issue in this mini-series, and up to this point, I really couldn't wait for it to end. I haven't really been enjoying the story, and I didn't really understand why anyone thought it needed to be told. But, this issue was a big improvement, and really redeemed the whole series for me.

In this issue, the entire storyline really comes together, and it will be easy for any reader to see what Hine was trying to do with the series. I think that with the revelations and resolutions that occur in this issue there has been a really substantial development in my mind for Colossus as a character. Any of you out there who weren't reading this series may want to consider picking up the trade if Marvel decides to release one. The rest of you: just stare at the beauty that was all five covers.

This one finishes strong in my mind, and this issue in particular is great,

My Verdict: 9/10

New Reviews Starting Tommorrow

2006-01-05T12:49:00.000-05:00

The holidays are over now, and as promised I will begin reviewing again. This week looks like it is going to be a light one, so I won't have too many reviews to do. In other news, I am through the first 9 volumes of Battle Royale which is a manga title that I highly recommend to all of you.

Anyway, enjoy the reviews.

See You Next Year!

2005-12-08T15:21:00.000-05:00

As some of you have realized, I have not updated the site in a few weeks. That trend will continue until the beginning of January. I need the time off for travel and holiday shopping etc. So, look for new reviews and items after New Year's. Until then: Happy Holidays!

REVIEW: Batman: Journey Into Knight #4

2005-11-23T09:33:00.000-05:00

Batman: Journey Into Knight #4
Publisher: DC
Writer: Andrew Helfer
Artist: Tan Eng Huat

Is anyone actually still enjoying this? I tried to read it last night and I couldn't even get through half of it. The story is just so boring and repetitive at this point, and the layout for the artwork is ridiculously hard to follow. Anytime I have to spend a few minutes staring at one page of a comic to try and figure out what is going on - there is a problem. The perspective changes completely from panel to panel so often that I have trouble deciding whether I am looking at a new scene entirely, or the same one from the panel before. As far as I am concerned there is no reason for any of you to be reading this.

My Verdict: 1/10

REVIEW: Books of Doom #1

2005-11-23T09:28:00.000-05:00

Books of Doom #1
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Ed Brubaker
Artist: Pablo Raimondi

I bought this title (like X-Men: Deadly Genesis) only because it is written by Ed Brubaker and I try to read as much by him as possible. I didn't really know what to expect with this one, but I was pleasantly surprised when I found that this issue had a pretty good story that was teaching me a lot about a character I don't know very well. This is basically an origin story, but with a lot more detail - and maybe a twist in later issues. The story is engrossing. It had me turning the page, and the artwork is very impressive. I am unfamiliar with Raimondi, but his work is noteworthy in this issue. This one is highly recommended.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: Fables #43

2005-11-23T09:20:00.000-05:00

Fables #43
Publisher: DC Vertigo
Writer: Bill Willingham
Artist: Mark Buckingham

[*mild spoilers*] After last issue, I was worried that this story arc would be uncharacteristically bad. But, after I finished this one - those fears were laid to rest. This issue is very good. The contingent from Iraq continues their negotiations, but it is revealed that they have brought powerful genies with them that can grant wishes and are very dangerous beings. Sinbad has taken a shine to the culture of Fabletown and that has his handlers worried. Read the issue to find out what they are going to do about it. This one is recommended.

My Verdict: 8/10

REVIEW: X-Men: Deadly Genesis #1

2005-11-21T17:28:00.000-05:00

X-Men: Deadly Genesis #1
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Ed Brubaker
Artist: Trevor Hairsine

You may be saying to yourself "Give me a break, another X-Title!?" And I would be saying that too if this title wasn't written by Ed Brubaker. The chance to read Brubaker writing an X-Men title was too much for me to skip over.

After reading the issue I am a little worried, as I didn't find this issue all that interesting. But I am willing to ride it out because few people in comics are as consistently good as Brubaker. This one is worth a look if you were into House of M at all or if you absolutely have to read every X-book.

My Verdict: 6.5/10

REVIEW: Thing #1

2005-11-21T17:09:00.000-05:00

The Thing #1
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Dan Slott
Artist: Andrea Di Vito

Because this was a new book by Dan Slott, there was no way I was going to miss it. Boy, am I glad I read it. I will not spoil anything here.

This issue is so damn good it is silly. The dialogue is standard Slott, with a lot of funny stuff. Including a great rip on Paris Hilton. The artwork is very good, and the story that is setup promises to be one of the most fun in a long time. The villain that is revealed on the last page left me dying to read the whole arc. None of you have any reason to not buy this issue - it is that fun.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: Spider-Man (Marvel Knights) #20

2005-11-21T16:42:00.000-05:00

Spider-Man (Marvel Knights) #20
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Reginald Hudlin
Artist: Pat Lee

[*mild spoilers*] I will save you all from reading my ongoing rant about this mini event and the lack of information we have regarding Spidey's "illness." I probably don't have to tell you that they don't reveal what it is here either. So, this issue takes a big hit for that. Storywise, I don't really understand what was happening at the beginning of the issue. I don't know why anyone felt this need to be an entire issue in the series; it could have fit on maybe 4 pages. In fact, the only bright spot in this issue, and it is only a marginal one, is that Pat Lee's artwork was better than I expected. But, that hardly saves this waste of shelf space. Do not buy this unless you are a completist.

My Verdict: 2/10

REVIEW: Green Arrow #56

2005-11-17T12:15:00.000-05:00

Green Arrow #56
Publisher: DC
Writer: Judd Winick
Artist: Ron Garney

[*mild spoilers*] It isn't very often that you find a comic that takes place midway through an arc that is still a suitable starting point for new readers. This issue is just that. Not only is it a great point to start, but it is also a very good issue. There is a good amount of suspense in this issue. Basically, Dr. Light has sent some super villains to keep Ollie busy while Dr. Light attacks his family. The portion of this issue dealing with Light's assault on the Queen kids it where the suspense takes place, and it is a good read. In addition, I really liked the artwork in this issue. Garney's layouts and the detail in many of his panels really made me smile. This issue is recommended for old and new readers alike.

My Verdict: 8/10

REVIEW: X-Men #177

2005-11-17T08:41:00.000-05:00

X-Men #177
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter Milligan
Artist: Salvador Larocca

[*mild spoilers*] Almost all of Marvel has become about the House of M now, but you don't need to know much about it to read this issue. Basically, about 90% of the earth's mutants have lost their powers; including some of the X-Men. In this issue, they battle some Sentinels that are in no way typical. The story is pretty good, and this is a quick read. I loved Larocca's work here. The artwork is really great, and the coloring sets the mood of the book perfectly. This one is recommended.

My Verdict: 7.5/10

REVIEW: Ghost Rider #3

2005-11-15T08:30:00.000-05:00

Ghost Rider #3
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Garth Ennis
Artist: Clayton Crain

I don't really know what to make of this mini series. It isn't really that good so far, but it isn't that bad. The story is okay, but is taking quite a while to really get going, and there is only so long that pretty pictures of GR riding his bike will hold my attention. I am afraid that time has passed.

The artwork is good, and I really do like the coloring on it. But, it doesn't look good at all on GR's face, which is an important part of this comic - duh. I can't really say anything overly negative or positive on this one. I have a mixed reaction just slightly positive - or at least hopeful.

My Verdict: 5.5/10

REVIEW: Gotham Central #37

2005-11-15T08:20:00.000-05:00

Gotham Central #37
Publisher: DC
Writer: Greg Rucka
Artist: Steve Lieber

Gotham Central has finally joined the Infinite Crisis, and guess what? It shouldn't have. While they are part of the DCU, the title does not really suit a superhero story, and no matter what you say, IC is a super-hero story.

This title has been consistently good for a long time now, but this new tie-in doesn't work for me, and it doesn't interest me. Read this one at your own risk.

My Verdict: 5/10

REVIEW: Infinite Crisis #2

2005-11-14T09:32:00.000-05:00

Infinite Crisis #2
Publisher: DC
Writer: Geoff Johns
Artist: Phil Jiminez

[*mild spoilers*] There is not better example of why IC is a better crossover event than House of M than this issue. I read House of M and was completely lost and bored. Conversely, I read IC and have been lost at times, but DC at least attempts to draw me back in. In the first issue of this mini, we got a short review of the four minis that lead up to this - that was helpful. In this issue, we get a great little recap of DC history pre-crisis, which will be of immeasurable value to many readers. It put me straight in just a few pages.

This issue answers some of the Power Girl issues that have been building up for months and hints at what this mini is building up to. The artwork is simply gorgeous, and there is so much story in this issue it took me almost 20 minutes to read. This is a very enjoyable read, and the DC history in it alone makes it worthwile.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: Y-The Last Man #39

2005-11-14T09:17:00.000-05:00

Y-The Last Man #39
Publisher: Vertigo
Writer: Brian K. Vaughan
Artist: Pia Guerra

[*mild spoilers*] This issue is the conclusion to the current storyline. A couple of important developments take place in this issue, and some of them will surprise you - slightly. This issue ties up a lot of the loose ends that were lurking in previous issues, and leaves me dying to read the next arc. The artwork is good as usual, and the dialogue is spot on; with the right amount of humor and suspense. If YTLM were a TV show, this is an episode you would not want to miss.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #2

2005-11-14T09:01:00.000-05:00

Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #2
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Reginald Hudlin
Artist: Mike Wieringo

[*mild spoilers*] Yet another issue without revealing what the #%@& is wrong with Peter. We get a few more hints, but nobody comes out and says it. It is definitely terminal, and I get the feeling that it is not anything that any of us are likely to have heard of. It will most likely be some super-hero version of cancer.

So, I have a problem with the fact that I still haven't been told what is wrong with Spidey, but I have a bigger problem with the fact that we are so far into this event and very little has happened. This issue is no exception. All around, it is a pretty boring issue.

My Verdict: 4/10

REVIEW: Jonah Hex #1

2005-11-08T08:51:00.000-05:00

Jonah Hex #1
Publisher: DC
Writer: Justin Gray and Jimmy Palmiotti
Artist: Luke Ross

[*spoiler warning*] I was anxiously awaiting this series' debut, and it turns out that it was worth the wait. First of all, it is good to finally get a western title that is high quality and interesting. Jonah Hex fits that bill. The first issue is a stand alone story, so it is ideal if you want to see if you like the series. It is basically a western mystery concerning Jonah's search for a young boy that has gone missing - for a fee of course. He finds the boy working as a dog fighter in the lawless west, fighting pitbulls in a ring in front of ravenous crowds. The tone of the book is dead on. It is dark, but it is dark for a reason and it fits the character perfectly.

The artwork is also very good. The style will not appeal to everyone, but I didn't have any problems with it. The computer colored "paint" look has grown on me over time, and I thought that it fit here. In addition, the artist is really good with facial expression, which helps make the story seem more real. This issue is highly recommended.

My Verdict: 9/10

REVIEW: Colossus: Bloodline #3

2005-11-08T08:40:00.000-05:00

Colossus: Bloodline #3
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: David Hine
Artist: Jorge Lucas

[*mild spoilers*] This mini series confounds me. There was a lot of potential here that seems to be eroding a little more with each issue. In this issue, we get an altered version of the history of Rasputin in which he is essentially a mutant that aids in the creation of other powerful mutants. Aside from being totally strange, this aspect of the story feels really forced at times. I find myself laughing in places I shouldn't be laughing - because it honestly gets really stupid at times. This issues two biggest draw backs, for me, were the amount of exposition used to tell the story and the low quality of the artwork. I don't like when authors tell us things they could show us, and that happens a lot in this issue. Concerning the artwork, I am not really sure what went wrong in this issue, but if you take a look at it you will notice that it looks very "choppy" with heavy amounts of ink everywhere. It just didn't do it for me. The issue overall is avoidable in my opinion.

My Verdict: 4/10

REVIEW: Batman: Gotham County Line #2

2005-11-07T10:02:00.000-05:00

Batman: Gotham County Line #2
Publisher: DC
Writer: Steve Niles
Artist: Scott Hampton

Wow, this mini is great. I absolutely love reading about Batman outside his comfort zone. In this series, he is fighting zombies and he's doing it outside of Gotham. For those of you upset with the characterization of Batman in some of his other titles, you may want to check this series out. Niles is writing a more classic Batman. The bonus with these issues is the unbelievably great artwork of Scott Hampton. I can't remember being so struck with the images in a book in a long time. This issue, and the entire series is highly recommended.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: Punisher (MAX) #27

2005-11-07T09:51:00.000-05:00

Punisher (MAX) #27
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Garth Ennis
Artist: Leo Fernandez

[*mild spoilers*] Punisher has been one of the better books that I am reading, especially lately. This current arc falls somewhere in the middle for me so far. I can't really say that I am into it as much as some of the previous arcs, but it may pick up. After all, we are only half way through it. This issue was pretty interesting. The cops that have been used to make the Punisher appear a danger to civilised society decide to fight back. The real fireworks will probably come next issue, but the seed is laid here. All around, this issue was average: nothing to spectacular, but nothing really bad either.

My Verdict: 7/10

REVIEW: Daredevil #78

2005-10-31T10:06:00.000-05:00

Daredevil #78
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Brian Michael Bendis
Artist: Alex Maleev

[*spoiler warning*] In this issue, we learn a lot more about the Kingpin's deal, and the info he will provide to the feds for his immunity. By the end of this issue we find Daredevil, Black Widow, Elektra and the new White Tiger all race to get to the information before the Feds can.

This issue was great. There is an immense amount of suspense and a real feeling that Matt Murdock could lose everything. The artwork is awesome, but that is just par for the course with Maleev. This is a must read for all Daredevil fans.

My Verdict: 10/10

REVIEW: The Sentry #2

2005-10-30T21:57:00.000-05:00

The Sentry #2
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Paul Jenkins
Artist: John Romita Jr.

The only reason I was reading this series was as a supplement to the New Avengers. I wanted to know more about the mysterious Sentry. After two issues, I doubt I will even still be reading by the fourth. I have decided that this series is really boring, and that I don't really care whether I understand the Senty or not. I like the New Avengers, and I'll just have to leave it at that. If I were you, I would not waste my time with this issue.

My Verdict: 1/10

REVIEW: Amazing Spider-Man #525

2005-10-30T21:50:00.000-05:00

Amazing Spider-Man #525
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter David
Artist: Mike Deodato Jr.

[*mild spoilers*] This is now the third issue in "The Other" crossover event, and I was really looking forward to finding out what the hell was wrong with Peter. You would think that after two issues with a cliffhanger ending, taunting us to read the next issue, they couldn't possibly tease us again. Well, you thought wrong. This issue ends with another cliffhanger where Peter is just about to reveal what is wrong with him. I for one am sick of it, and am starting to feel cheated. Aside from the first issue in this crossover, there has been little in the way of story and this issue is no exception. The only part of this issue of value is the artwork. Deodato did a nice job. This issue gets a big thumb down from me.

My Verdict: 2/10

REVIEW: New Avengers #12

2005-10-28T09:17:00.000-05:00

New Avengers #12
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Brian Michael Bendis
Artist: David Finch

[*spoiler warning*] While I didn't feel this issue was a strong as previous issues as an overall enjoyable read, there is one major plot development that makes it an essential read for fans of the series. Here it comes. If you don't want to know, stop reading. Spider-Woman is the mole in the New Avengers. It is revealed that she is the one working with HYDRA. That is a big development to say the least, and it really makes me want to keep reading this series. Aside from that little tidbit, there is some great artwork in this issue. So, the story isn't that enchanting for most of the issue, but the twist saves the issue.

My Verdict: 8/10

REVIEW: Black Widow 2 #2

2005-10-27T22:19:00.000-05:00

Black Widow 2 #2
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Richard K. Morgan
Artist: Sean Phillips

Before I review this issue, I must confess that I was not in a "comic-reading" mood before I sat down with it. So, plot wise I am not going to comment because I don't want to come down unfairly on something that I wasn't in the mood to read at the time.

Basically, this is a strong issue. The plot is slightly difficult to follow, but the dialogue is great. I will again praise Phillips' art - it is really spectacular. In short, this issue is worth a look, especially if you have been following this, and the last, Widow mini.

My Verdict: 7/10

REVIEW: Captain America #11

2005-10-27T07:50:00.000-05:00

Captain America #11
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Ed Brubaker
Artist: Steve Epting

[*mild spoilers*] This issue reads less like a comic book and more like an illustrated story. That is fine with me because it was really good. The story is basically a page by page look at a top secret file from the Soviet Union on Bucky. It confirms what most people suspect - that he is indeed alive. You have to read this issue for the details, and let me just say that you really should read this.

Each of the events that is described in the file has an illustration to accompany it. The art work is quite good, and the illustrations chosen fit perfectly with each successive tidbit of information. This issue is highly recommended to anyone remotely interested in Cap.

My Verdict: 9.5/10

REVIEW: Batman: Journey Into Knight #3

2005-10-24T07:42:00.000-05:00

Batman: Journey Into Knight #3
Publisher: DC
Writer: Andy Helfer
Artist: Tan Eng Huat

Every once in a while, a comic will come along that makes you wonder why you are reading a title at all. This is that comic. This series has been inconsistent for me. I didn't really care for the first issue, but I felt that the second issue represented considerable improvement and felt better about the series on the whole. This issue is worst so far. Not only does Helfer (the writer) use far too much exposition to tell ut what is going on, but the artwork is again nearly impossible to follow. Huat's artwork is decent in that the drawings in each panel are pretty, but the way each panel relates to the next is completely illogical. These two factors made the book nearly unreadable for me.

My Verdict: 1/10

REVIEW: Nick Fury's Howling Commandos #1

2005-10-22T17:56:00.000-05:00

Nick Fury's Howling Commandos #1
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Keith Giffen
Artist: Edu Francisco

I was sort of looking forward to reading this new series, but now I don't think I will even buy the second issue. Maybe this just isn't my type of comic, but I suspect I am not alone in my opinion.

The story here is impossible to follow. It made no sense to me and I found myself hoping that the next page would be the last. In addition to this, the artwork bothered me. It wasn't that bad in terms of artistry, but every panel had so much crap in it that it made it difficult to tell what was happening. As you can see from the cover, these characters have millions of pouches belts and pockets all over them. If more than one of them is in a panel - lookout. It will take you 30 seconds to figure out what's going on. Don't waste your time or your money on this.

My Verdict: 1/10

REVIEW: Ultimate Fantastic Four #24

2005-10-21T10:23:00.000-05:00

Ultimate Fantastic Four #24
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Mark Millar
Artist: Greg Land

[*spoiler warning*] A new story arc begins here, and as you have probably guessed from the cover and the arc's title (which is also on the cover) that this arc is going to involve Ultimate Namor. What you didn't know, I will now tell you. Johnny and Sue's mother (who was presumed dead) has returned to everyone's surprise. Well, seems she was on a top secret mission for the last fifteen years searching for the lost continent of Atlantis. And, what you know? She found it. While she will probably not be winning any Mother of the Year awards, she does offer the F4 the oppurtunity to be the first to explore the site. But really, they are the only ones who could survive the dive. So, they go down there and they see... Namor. The end.

The issue isn't too bad. I am not going to say that the story here is that wonderful, but there is a nice dynamic setting up between Sue and her mother, and that should be really interesting. The art is great in this issue. I like Land's a lot, and the colorist on this issue did a really nice job. Underwater imagery can tough, but it looks great here.

My Verdict: 7/10

REVIEW: Justice #2

2005-10-20T12:07:00.000-05:00

Justice #2
Publisher: DC
Writer: Jim Krueger, Alex Ross
Artist: Doug Braithwaite, Alex Ross

[*mild spoilers*] This title is very new, but still very interesting. Obviously, the fact that Alex Ross is doing the artwork is a big reason why so many people are buying it; but the story is pretty decent too. Now, I am not going to say that I absolutely adore it yet (my review of the first issue was slightly critical), but this issue was pretty good. This has a great Batman-centered tale in which the Riddler breaks into Wayne Enterprises in order to use a computer that is fast enough to download a secret document containing Batman's identity. Needless to say, Batman won't let that fly, so he gives chase. Read the issue to find out what happens.

Also in this issue, there is more story concerning Aquaman. This aspect of issue #1 troubled, and while the reason for Aquaman's part in the story becomes clearer in this issue, there is still a long way to go until I understand. It does seem clear though that Ross intends to use Aquaman as the springboard for the larger story. This is heavily supported by the villain that appears on the final page of this issue. You'll have to read the book for that tidbit also. Pick this one up, it is pretty good.

My Verdict: 8.5/10

REVIEW: She-Hulk 2 #1

2005-10-19T23:06:00.000-05:00

She-Hulk 2 #1
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Dan Slott
Artist: Juan Bobillo

[*mild spoilers*] Long time readers of FBM know that I really liked the first She-Hulk series from last year. So, I could not wait to read this issue, and I'll be damned: it was awesome. This issue is so packed with story it took me almost 20 minutes to read it. Most comics take me about 4 minutes to finish, but this one is jam packed. I love the way Slott packs so much into this issue. I love the way he riffs on comic culture. There is a great bit in this issue about trade paperbacks. As a side note, I actually found out about this bit last year when I met Slott at my comic shop. In a discussion with him, he was telling me about this great bit with the trades that he was doing. I thought it was funny then and I thought it was funny now.

Anyway, I am not going to spoil the story for you, but you should all pick this up. It is funny and it is engaging, and it is the best value around. Some may complain about the art, but to be honest it isn't that bad. And besides, you don't read a Dan Slott book for the artwork. You read it for the Slott. Rush out and get this book!

My Verdict: 9.5/10

REVIEW: X-Men #176

2005-10-19T22:59:00.000-05:00

X-Men #176
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter Milligan
Artist: Salvador Larocca

What the f*** is going on? This current story arc makes very little sense at best. Maybe Milligan is going somewhere with this, but he has a way to go. This issue confused the hell out of me. Basically, if you like Planet of the Apes or mad scientists you will love this issue. If, like me, you like the X-Men, you should probably stay away from this. Honestly, this issue was wild. It made very little sense to me. The art was pretty good though. I like Larocca's work here a lot.

My Verdict: 3/10

REVIEW: Colossus Bloodline #2

2005-10-19T22:52:00.000-05:00

Colossus Bloodline #2
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: David Hine
Artist: Jorge Lucas

[*mild spoilers*] Ok, so in the last issue we learned that Colossus might be a descendant of Rasputin... whatever, make with the shiny skin stomp stomp already. In this issue, that theory gets a little more weight and we glimpse Colossus kicking ass, if only for 3 panels. I didn't really like this issue very much, and the art was not doing anything for me, so it won't score well. There is "shocking" ending, but not all that shocking. Check it out if you are intersested, but you may just want to read it at your comic shop.

My Verdict: 5/10

REVIEW: Snake Eyes Declassified #3

2005-10-19T21:35:00.000-05:00

Snake Eyes: Declassified #3
Publisher: Devil's Due Press
Writer: Brandon Jerwa
Artist: Robert Atkins

[*mild spoilers*] This issue was a little better than I was expecting, a little. Snake Eyes starts his ninja training, and there is a good bit of action. The story is compact and somewhat engaging. Basically, he helps his new mentors fight off a traitor in their ranks. In the process a rift develops between him and his friend, Tommy. By the way, Tommy will definitely become Storm Shadow. Don't believe me? Check out this issue and you will have no further doubt.

All things considered, this issue isn't bad. The story is tight and there is plenty of action. Atkins' pencils are good when it comes to action sequences, but weak when it comes to conveying facial expressions and subtlety. Anyway, this one is a safe bet, it isn't that bad.

My Verdict: 7/10

REVIEW: Spider-Man (MK) #19

2005-10-19T21:27:00.000-05:00

Spider-Man (MK) #19
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter David
Artist: Pat Lee

[*mild spoilers*] I am only buying this because I am reading this whole "Other" storyline nonsense. As I have said before, this arc could easily just go into any of the existing titles without needing to interrupt all of them and start a new Spidey title.

So, after last issue (FNSM #1) where we find out that Spidey has some serious medical problem on the last page, this issue will tell us what that is. Right? WRONG! That's right, though the cover implies it, we have to wait for the next issue (hopefully) to find out what the frig it is. My money is on genital warts. What about you?

Instead of anything of substance in this issue, we get yet another yawn fest dealing with MJ and Peter's relationship. We get to see do a little ass kicking and play pool - that's about it. All of this is brought to life by the underwhelming pencils of Pat Lee. I loved him on the Transformers, but I don't like the way he draws people. This is another issue you should avoid.

My Verdict: 3/10

REVIEW: Robin #143

2005-10-19T21:17:00.000-05:00

Robin #143
Publisher: DC
Writer: Bill Willingham
Artist: Scott McDaniel

The cover clearly states OMAC Project tie-in, and there are enough OMACs in this book for everyone. And they are all speaking that annoying robot talk that continues throughout the issue. We get it, they change their specs based on who they're fighting. Now, stop ruining the comics by having them talk so much.

With that out of the way, I can tell you all to not waste your time with this issue. This title is precariously close to dropping from my pull list. This issue was so hard for me to understand, and so unnecessary I can't believe it was greenlighted. The only reason this was made, I suspect, was so they could sell to all the idiots that are buying every Crisis related issue. I know little about the characters in Robin, and clearly you need a vast knowledge to fully "get" this issue. The art isn't even that good. Don't waste your money.

My Verdict: 1.5/10

A lot of reviews this week

2005-10-19T12:30:00.000-05:00

As you can see by the box on the upper right of this page, I am reviewing a lot of books this week. So, be patient and I will try to post 3 or 4 a day.

Thanks

REVIEW: Fables #42

2005-10-14T15:55:00.000-05:00

Fables #42
Publisher: DC/Vertigo
Writer: Bill Willingham
Artist: Mark Buckingham

Wow, this issue was pretty bad. I have little to no interest so far in this storyline, and this book is tough to keep reading as you go. The story concerns fables from the mideast - little else can be said at this point. It is a real shame that this issue was so bad because I really enjoyed the Homelands arc.

Oh Well.

My Verdict: 3/10

REVIEW: Y-The Last Man #38

2005-10-14T13:06:00.000-05:00

Y-The Last Man #38
Publisher: DC/Vertigo
Writer: Brian K. Vaughan
Artist: Pia Guerra

[*mild spoilers*] The middle story in the current 3 part story arc, this one finds Yorick and 355 chasing down the reporter that snapped a photo of Yorick naked (see last issue). By now everyone is familiar with Guerra's work, so it will come as no surprise that it was good in this issue.

My main problem is that this issue feels a little "light" to me - at least in the story department. I didn't really feel like enough happened. We find out a bit more about 355's past but very little actual story takes place. This issue is surprisingly weak for what is otherwise an amazing comic.

My Verdict: 6/10

REVIEW: Green Arrow #55

2005-10-14T08:25:00.000-05:00

Green Arrow #55
Publisher: DC
Writer: Judd Winick
Artist: Ron Garney

[*spoiler warning*] This is the second issue in the current story arc. Basically, we find out that Mirror Master and Killer Frost were dispatched to keep Green Arrow an Black Lightning busy so that Dr. Light can attack Ollie's family.

This is an issue concerned almost solely with the fight. There is not much in the way of story. So, if you like looooonnnngggg fight scenes, you will love this issue. I don't really like reading a fight scene for 15 pages, so I didn't really like it.

My Verdict: 5/10

REVIEW: Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #1

2005-10-13T15:47:00.000-05:00

Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #1
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Peter David
Artist: Mike Wieringo

[*mild spoilers*] This issue marks the beginning of a new four month spider-man event which will see nearly all of spidey's titles continue this storyline - yippy! If you can't see the sarcasm there, adjust your monitor. I do not understand why we need to be put through this so often as comic readers. I can't stand feeling compelled to read arcs that crossover titles, especially when they only include other titles to boost sales. You want to tell a new spider story? - fine. But put it in one of the several Spidey titles already coming out every month.

Anyway, after reading this issue I don't know that I will last all four months. This issue was somewhat interesting but lacked the normally wonderful feeling that a new number one issue has. A somewhat cool villain and the ability to guess at what disease Peter has are the only things that merit mention here. This one was a letdown.

My Verdict: 4/10

REVIEW: Infinite Crisis #1

2005-10-13T08:35:00.000-05:00

Infinite Crisis #1
Publisher: DC
Writer: Geoff Johns
Artist: Phil Jiminez

[*mild spoilers*] Most of you have either read this story or have read a spoiler of it somewhere online by now so I am not too worried about ruining it, but I will keep my plot summary somewhat cryptic just in case. I picked the Perez cover for this review because A) I like it better, B) I thought Jim Lee's cover was a little ugly and C) Perez, at least, has some connection to the 80's Crisis event. Jim Lee doing a cover is clearly DC trying to make us all buy two copies, and I don't want to support that - even though I did by both of them.

Now to the story. This was a good start to the mini. This issue summarizes most of the storylines leading up to now, including all four Crisis minis. So, if you aren't that familiar with what is going on, you won't be too lost. This issue also has the distinction of being absolutely jam packed with story. I am not kidding, a lot happens in this issue. The Freedom fighters get their ass absolutely kicked, and Wonder Woman, Batman and Superman argue like rabid fanboys about whether a superhero should kill. Readers of FBM know that I think they should. And in the final panels, an old friend returns. That's as far as I want to go describing the plot because there is much more to discuss here.

Here are some random thoughts I had after reading this issue. I think Diana (Wonder Woman) will die in this mini-series. My reason for feeling this way is very simple: she killed someone. While I fully support that, DC editorial has historically not. Not to mention that the rest of the heroes in the DCU are clearly against it - well, at least the heavy hitters are. So, I think she is now painted as someone less worthy of being called "hero," and thus more readily killable. The second thought I had concerned whether or not I felt that the issue lived up to the hype. I will say to anyone that is complaining already that this is only the first isse of the series. I am not willing to pass judgement on the whole event just yet. This was a solid start, and I think this has every oppurtunity at this point to meet or exceed my expectations.

Finally, we come to the art. Jiminez really outdid himself here. Make no mistake, this book is beautiful. The art work here is just astounding. I was not expecting this book to be so well laid out, with such unbelievable pencils - but wow. There are a couple splash pages here that will knock your socks off, and the fight scenes are perfect. The art is worth the price of admission.

So, I liked it - pick it up (like you needed me to tell you).

My Verdict: 8.5/10

REVIEW: Ghost Rider #2

2005-10-12T22:57:00.000-05:00

Batman: Ghost Rider #2
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Garth Ennis
Artist: Clayton Crain

[*mild spoilers*] The second issue of this new mini series and really the first signs of the story to come. I don't want to totally ruin it for you so I am going to do a synopsis in one sentence. Here goes:

A fat, rich guy in a wheelchair is in league with a demon while GR is offered a deal by the archangel.

Read the issue to find out the details. My overall opinion is pretty good. There are a couple of stupid cliche moments, but they don't ruin the story. The art is pretty cool, if a little on the computerish side. That actually lends itself to the scenes with GR on his bike, but feels kind of flat when people are just talking. GR looks really weird when he is talking. But this issue wasn't that bad.

My Verdict: 7/10

What I'm Buying (Week of 10/12/05)

2005-10-12T13:01:00.000-05:00

From Marvel

Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man #1
Ghost Rider #2
House of M #7
Marvel Monsters: Where Monsters Dwell
Ultimate X-Men #64
Wolverine #34

From DC

Ex Machina #15
Fables #42
Green Arrow #55
Infinite Crisis #1 (both covers)
JLA #120
Y-The Last Man #38

REVIEW: Batman: Gotham County Line #1

2005-10-06T15:40:00.000-05:00

Batman: Gotham County Line #1
Publisher: DC
Writer: Steve Niles
Artist: Scott Hampton

[*spoiler warning*] I have been looking forward to this title for a few months now, and I am happy it is finally here. Let me start by saying that this starts out as a non-typical Niles tale and finishes firmly in his territory. As a murder mystery, this book is good, if a bit rushed. But I suspect it feels rushed so that Niles could get to the payoff at the end of the book: the zombies. I suspect the final two issues will be classic Niles, and a joy to read. I like the idea of Batman outside his element, in this case, he will be in the suburbs battling zombies.

The art here is ridiculously good. Hampton's work is absolutely amazing - I loved it. The book is almost worth the cover price just for the art. Definitely treat yourself this week and pick a copy of this up. It is highly recommended.

My Verdict: 9.5/10

REVIEW: Gotham Central #36

2005-10-06T14:02:00.000-05:00

Gotham Central #36
Publisher: DC
Writer: Greg Rucka and Ed Brubaker
Artist: Kano

[*spoiler warning*] I was really looking forward to this issue as it was the conclusion to the Dead Robins story arc. I have to say, I'm a little disappointed. The evidence was pointing toward Batman as the suspect, but everyone knew it wasn't him. Instead, the killer and the police leak are revealed in this issue. I won't tell you who either are, but I will say that neither is really all that shocking, and the killer is a major letdown, with a very stupid motive.

The art is pretty good, so the book has that going for it. Other than that, you should only pick this up if you are a completist, really want to know what happens, or just have a lot of money and don't care what you spend it on.

My Verdict: 4.5/10

REVIEW: Punisher (MAX) #26

2005-10-06T09:49:00.000-05:00

Punisher (MAX) #26
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Garth Ennis
Artist: Leo Fernandez

[*mild spoilers*] This is the second part in a new arc. We here the young immigrant's story about how she was forced into prostitution and the people she worked for. We also see more of the people that Frank will be going after in the coming issues. Also in this issue, we see that the police intend to pursue the Punisher with a greater amount of conviction than they have in the past. They even go as far as dressing the two assaulted officers up in all kinds of bandages and braces for a press conference.

This was an interesting issue, but one is left thinking that the really good stuff is yet to come in this arc.

My Verdict: 7/10

REVIEW: Wonder Woman #221

2005-10-05T22:45:00.000-05:00

Wonder Woman #221
Publisher: DC
Writer: Greg Rucka
Artist: Rags Morales

[*mild spoilers*] I am still struggling to understand this book. I only just started reading Wonder Woman, so I have found myself slightly confused of late. To compound that problem, this issue is an Omac Project tie-in, and I will not be reading Omac until the trade is available, but I do have something that I want to talk about as it relates to this issue.

Basically, in this issue, Wonder Woman confronts the murder she committed, and the news actually airs the tape of the murder - which shocks the public. What I want to say is that I really support superheroes killing evil people. After all, the villains have no problem killing people, so why not eliminate them once and for all. It really is the greater good. I understand the objections to this view, but those objections always come off as unrealistic to me. If killing someone is the only way to stop them from killing countless others, I don't really have a problem with it.

That said, this issue was confusing, but good none the less. I especially liked the artwork. Since I first saw Morales's work in Identity Crisis, I have been impressed, and the artwork here really stands out. Those of you collecting the whole Infinite Crisis event will probably really enjoy this issue. I enjoyed it, and I am barely reading any IC related titles right now.

My Verdict: 8/10

REVIEW: Fell #2

2005-10-05T22:32:00.000-05:00

Fell #2
Publisher: Image
Writer: Warren Ellis
Artist: Ben Templesmith

As I have said before, I like this new title. Granted, I had only read one issue, but now I have read two, and I still hold that opinion. This issue lacked a little of the magic that the first one held for me, but it was still very good. My main problem with this issue is that the story was somewhat weak by the standard set by issue #1. There are some good moments here, and it is certainly macabre, but it didn't have the same impact on me that the first story had. This issue would have benefitted from a few more pages.

The art here is again brilliant. Templesmith's style really appeals to me. And the price is still only $1.99, which is great. Sure, you are getting a little less content, but that shouldn't matter once Ellis starts writing multi-part stories. This issue is recommended.

My Verdict: 8.5/10

REVIEW: New Avengers #11

2005-09-30T07:33:00.000-05:00

New Avengers #11
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Brian Michael Bendis
Artist: David Finch

[*spoiler warning*] This issue marks the beginning of a new story arc. It also marks the first issue featuring that lovely character on the cover.

In this issue, Daredevil still refuses Cap's request to join the new team, but offers up someone he trusts to help the team with their current problem - the guy on the cover.

This issue was a bit interesting and well drawn but little else. The cliffhanger was tame in my opinion. Okay. I'm going to go ahead and stop, I'm running out of things to say about this one.

My Verdict: 6/10

REVIEW: Wolverine #33

2005-09-29T07:35:00.000-05:00

Wolverine #33
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Daniel Way
Artist: Mark Texeira

This issue is the first post-Millar issue in the series, and it is part of the ongoing snooze fest Marvel calls House of M. I am reading a few of the other House of M books, including the main title, but I am so uninterested at this point, I could have done without Wolverine's title being pulled into it. This issue is relatively harmless, and does the best it can with the whole "House of M" thing. But, it just wasn't all that interesting. There is nothing overly interesting or entertaining here. Texeira's finishes are nice, and the art is actually the highlight of the issue for me. I'll have to wait for House of M to end before I really get interested in this title. Until then, don't bother with this issue.

My Verdict: 6/10

REVIEW: Black Widow 2 #1

2005-09-29T07:11:00.000-05:00

Black Widow 2 #1
Publisher: Marvel
Writer: Richard K. Morgan
Artist: Sean Phillips

[*mild spoilers*] This new mini basically picks up where the last one left off. I really liked the last BW mini, so I was excited for this series to be released. I had a little trouble remembering the whole plot from the last mini series, and I was too lazy to go back and re-read, but after a little while I started to remember.

In this issue, BW goes to Cuba to meet up with an old "friend." She is quickly talked into helping her friend by roughing up some drug runner mafia guys back in Miami that have not delivered the drugs and are demanding more money. While she is busting them up, she makes a surprising discovery, but you have to read the issue for that bit of info.

I love the artwork here, Sean Phillips' style is really appealing to me. The sketchiness of it, and the flat coloring really make it look cool. That combined with a great story, and really good dialogue make this an issue that I highly recommend.

My Verdict: 9/10